Reconciling the chemistry and biology of reactive oxygen species

Winterbourn CC (2008) Nature Chemical Biology
hydrogen-peroxide-therapy hydrogen-peroxide reactive-oxygen-species immune-function biochemistry
Title and abstract of Reconciling the chemistry and biology of reactive oxygen species

Key Takeaway

H2O2 plays a key role in immune cell function, but systemic H2O2 therapy lacks evidence for enhancing immunity.

Summary

This review reconciles chemical reactivity of H2O2 with its biological functions, particularly in immunity.

Immune functions of H2O2:

  • Neutrophils produce H2O2 via respiratory burst
  • Part of antimicrobial defense system
  • Works with myeloperoxidase to form hypochlorous acid
  • Localized production at site of infection

The respiratory burst:

ComponentFunction
NADPH oxidaseProduces superoxide
SODConverts to H2O2
MPOConverts H2O2 to HOCl
HOClDirect antimicrobial

Key insight:

The immune system's use of H2O2 is highly targeted and localized. Systemic H2O2 administration doesn't replicate this - it's like using a firehose instead of a water pistol.

Problems with therapy logic:

  • Immune H2O2 is produced where needed
  • Systemic H2O2 doesn't target pathogens
  • May cause collateral oxidative damage
  • Body already makes plenty of H2O2

What this means:

The immune system's natural H2O2 use doesn't validate drinking or injecting H2O2. These are fundamentally different delivery systems with different effects.

Clinical relevance:

Provides biological basis for H2O2 in immunity but does not support therapeutic H2O2 administration.

Related Interventions

Related Studies

Source

View on PubMed →

DOI: 10.1038/nchembio.85